fn slp tactical vs benelli m4

In addition, because the failures are present in multiple bars it would seem to indicate that the user was not a factor in increasing failures. Nor even do they mention the basic fact that there are two different gas cylinders for the FN, and that they must be swapped out depending on whether one is shooting light low base or heavy high base loads. Benelli M4 has excellent aftermarket support for a tactical configuration, but it's heavy and expensive. In the end, it appears that the reliability of the shotgun in question is highly variable. I would have liked to see a Saiga and an M4 in the mix too. Obviously a lot more testing would be required to validate their claims, hence why I said “but further testing will be required to make any kind of a definitive answer.” I do admit to being biased towards the 930 SPX (because I’m the owner), but I feel that in the testing my own bias was balanced out by the bias of the SLP owner, and the relatively unbiased assistants we used. The build quality alone is tangible between the two guns which is a reflection of the way FN builds guns vs Mossberg- Mossberg makes decent stuff at a solid price FN makes top quality fire arms to include the SLP…get it straight wingnuts. Clearly your own tests showed problems with the 930 SPX. Firearms reliability on the civilian market hasn’t been well tested. I have a Mossberg, and other brands of shotgun but only shoot my FNH. Supposedly this is the gun that settles the Mossberg SPX vs. FN SLP vs. Remington Versa-Max tactical debate. With production shotguns where thousands of units are produced, a sample population of dozens or even hundreds of shotguns would be required to get within a 95% confidence interval for the results. In contrast, the Mossberg has no way to adjust its gas system for different ammunition. I and had a significant personal interest in seeing that his shotgun won. Brilliant, Mr. Jacobs, you beat me to it. I think the FN will be less expensive. What this article says to me is the Mossberg can reliably compete with the higher priced shotguns but in all fairness to both shotguns high power loads should have been used. However, we did not have the time, the money or the shotguns to use a sample that large. I never thought I would read something by someone using R on a gun website. We offer these in semi auto , pump action magazine fed and Bull pup configurations. I shot well over 1000 shells from light bird to buck. That's also true of the Mossberg, by the way. I does indeed come with two gas pistons and the manual does say that light loads will properly cycle with the “light” piston installed. As was indicated by the manual for the SLP Mk. I’ll try to remember to update this thread with what I find. We chose 500 rounds based on the average published round count for shotguns in 3-gun events. And you know I have had complaints with every owner on reliability. 25 rounds of Federal XM127 9 pellet 00 buckshot that fires at 1325FPS. In addition, the failures occur for both Winchester and Remington ammunition indicating that ammunition type was not a factor. Yet, you now actually contradict yourself and claim that every 930 SPX that you are aware of “works all the time every time”. both the FNH-SPL and Bennelli M4 are great shotguns. The SLP It's light Less cost prohibiting Holds two extra rounds and is 922r compliant Holds 9 if you ghost one the M4 holds seven while ghosting one. get educated .and if it still doesn’t wanna survive get a pump. I managed to have one pushrod in the gas system shear off and jam inside the action, but Mossberg replaced it free. So, in response to your complaint, we were fully aware of the need to change the gas pistons and we did indeed ensure that the proper piston was installed. We cleaned, lubricated and inspected them meticulously before the contest, as competitors would before a match. The T statistic was 0.144 (which, with 37.83 degrees of freedom, indicates that any differences in means is probably a chance finding), the P-Value in this test was 0.8863, and the 95% confidence interval was closely straddling zero (-2.612411, 3.012411). Can someone tell me the advantages of each? I don't think the M4 is worth it with the 1301 out now, though, and the fact that the 1301 costs about $1,000 less. Grammar Nazi alert! Following the completion of testing a survey was taken of the participants to determine which shotgun they preferred. I owners who have returned their shotguns due to reliability issues. I have had this gun for 15 years. The FNH SLP shoots faster, holds more ammo and costs about $600 less then the revered Benelli. “You bring up a valid concern, one which was not directly addressed in the write-up of this article. The FN SLP is based on the same action as the Winchester Super X2, which is a proven design (and I have both a FN SLP and a Winchester SX2). While they were disassembled we referred to the manuals for each shotgun to ensure that they were properly configured for the testing to come. At which point a few of the other shooters pointed out that I needed to adjust stance so that my body was behind the gun. In terms of ease of operation, however, only 67% preferred the 930 SPX to the FNH SLP. My FN SLP Mk 1 has been perfect from the start. I have a tendency to plant my feet almost one behind the other when facing target, and I don’t lean forward. If the Mossberg 930x is so superior, why are SLP’s the winning all the major three gun titles??? 25 rounds of Federal LE132 9 pellet 00 buckshot that fires at 1125 FPS It’s true that I own the Mossberg 930 SPX in question, Ben (who helped write this report) owned the SLP Mk. The first metric of the test was whether both shotguns were still functioning at the conclusion of the test. I malfunctioned more often than a randomly chosen Mossberg 930 SPX. If yours don’t . If you added a mag extension or full-length tube, the M4 would hold 9. Sounds to me like someone has a an agenda promoting Mossberg. All authors are members of AwfulShootingSquad.com, The authors of this paper conducted a 500 round stress test to determine if either of two semi-automatic shotguns, an FNH SLP Mk. You asked for it and we got it – a Benelli M4 Civilian. Go on YouTube, there are a lot of videos about them. The FN SLP was a contender maybe 5 years ago, but the plethora of better alternatives makes it a poor choice now. SLP all the way! I have shot numerous rounds of both trap and sporting clays with my FN SLP Mk 1 using very light target ammo, and it functions 100% perfectly, AS LONG AS I HAVE THE LIGHT LOADS CYLINDER INSTALLED! As far as i am concerned the SLP cannot touch these two shotguns and for near the same price as a SLP, you can get a M2 Tactical. Description: Benelli M1014 Limited Edition Midnight Bronze 12ga 3in Semi Automatic Shotgun - 18.5in - Benelli's M4 Tactical is a unique, Auto Regulating Gas Operated (A.R.G.O) semi-auto shotgun, upon which the U.S. Marine Corps depend. First, to determine if a modern semi-automatic shotgun would be subjected to enough wear (defined as fowling and residue produced as a byproduct of the firing of the firearm) during the course of a typical 3-gun competition to cause a malfunction. http://i154.photobucket.com/albums/s272/lanceJOregon/guns/SHOT1.jpg. Nick leghorn- So whats the good word on your new FN to test? Second, to determine what differences, if any, were present between the 2 shotguns considered in the test. If only gun magazines did tests this thoroughly…. Since my last posting I have become an owner of the SLP MKI and let me tell you through my informal testing it has fired and cycled every round I have put through it. This comparison is garbage. But what can you say the Mossberg really is a get what you pay for gun. I do evetrthing from three gun to sporting clays and turkey hunting with my FN and have had zero problems. That being said, I can find just as many complaints about the FN online if I want to find them. This is my kind of review. Such a statement cannot come across as being anything other than biased.” – Lance Jacobs, “Every 930 SPX I’ve fired and every 930 SPX owner I’ve talked to has said that their shotgun works all the time every time. However have you Looked at the Benelli M2 or M4? It has spotty reliability – sometimes fails to extract/eject, stovepipes, does not like a side saddle, been to Mossberg twice (replaced with new gun once). Not for anything. If you speak to any of the other authors involved (listed on the report) they will independently verify my statement. While they were disassembled we referred to the manuals for each shotgun to ensure that they were properly configured for the testing to come. In writing the “paper” all people involved edited the text, including the SLP owner, to try and eliminate as much bias as possible. And that then created these invalid test results. I wanted to update my first comment to correct the remark I made about my front sight not being canted. However definitive that plot may look the bar graph below, illustrating total failures per box for each of the 20 boxes of ammunition, may indicate a reason. I don't know much about the Benelli M4, but if it's good enough for the USMC (and LAPD for that matter) it's GTG too. This discrepancy could possibly be explained as the SLP’s break-in period (the number of rounds required to put the proper level of polish on the operating mechanism for it to begin to function normally) as the shotgun was used extremely lightly (less than 200 rounds) prior to the testing. The night prior to the test we fully disassembled both shotguns and gave them a thorough cleaning. Any production gun will have problems, my friends Benelli M4 has had cycling issues too. I have seen more than one of each model in operation and the FN has Never sent a competitor off course due to malfunction. And have someone clean it for you because obviously you suck at it. https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/irregardless, “The most frequently repeated remark about it is that “there is no such word.” There is such a word, however.”, The link also classifies it as non-standard, points to regardless, and after your cherry-picked quote goes on to say “Its reputation has not risen over the years, and it is still a long way from general acceptance. I previously owned the Mossberg 930 SPX and liked it.It was light and FAST! There is no doubt in my mind now that there must have been something wrong with the FN tested. But for gas autoloaders Beretta simply makes the best. Hits and misses were recorded by an observer, as well as any mechanical malfunctions. Thanks to the Pennsylvania Game Commission for the use of its Scotia shotgun range as the testing facility (State Game Lands No. Mossberg admits to having a few quality control issues & sight mounting. A detailed review of the Benelli M4 12 gauge combat shotgun or M1014. Such a statement cannot come across as being anything other than biased. [Conclusion redacted for the sake of dramatic tension.]. In the world of 3-gun competitions the shotgun provides a unique challenge for the competitors. And as I said earlier, my FN SLP Mk I runs flawless, much better than your Mossberg 930 SPX performed in this test. FN SLP reliability/operation vs Benelli M4? FN is giving us another to test shortly, we’ll see if that has an issue as well. Your comments that I have quoted below are pure hearsay, with no real facts or data to back them up. I know the M4 is an excellent shotgun and I will be getting one at a later date. AR-15 AK-47 Handgun Precision Rifles Armory Training Competitive Shooting General Outdoors Archery Hometown Industry. - If you are used to shooting trap and skeet. This test was initiated with two specific goals. The number and frequency seemed incredibly high compared to what I’ve seen with older semi shotguns. check out the. As the graphic above shows, the final results of the test indicate that an FNH SLP is likely to have approximately five failures for every 25 rounds of ammunition, while the number of failures for the Mossberg 930 SPX is not statistically significant. “The remarks that I am referring to are quoted at the very end of this post. This test was intended to solve a question related to functioning of shotguns during a competition. All we have to go on to determine which shotgun is superior is personal experience and gun store scuttlebutt. In the course of our work, we logged other performance results to further determine which shotgun best suits 3-gun competition. It is more likely that a semi-automatic shotgun will malfunction in the middle of a stage than a pump action shotgun, costing the competitor precious seconds clearing that jam. If you speak to any of the other authors involved (listed on the report) they will independently verify my statement.” – Foghorn. A great amount of time, effort and personal funds went into making this test as fair and accurate as possible, and I have not received a single penny in payment as a result from anyone. -They both hold 7 rounds in OEM configuration when fully loaded. Reminds me of “Dog ate the homework.” story. Good luck on the new testing and I hope your new FN performs like mine does. According to conventional wisdom, the number of rounds fired and the abuse the firearm has received since its last cleaning is the principal factor which increases the probability of malfunctions in semi-automatic firearms. I as have defended it. This is my first post, I own a Supernova and just bought a FN SLP. These shells are easily capable of headshot groups at 25 yards and I want tight groups. ARCHIVED; Armory » Shotguns. The Benelli M4 is pretty much failure-proof, but it's even more expensive than an M2 and you're stuck with its short barrel and ghost sights (or an optic). Written by Nicholas Leghorn, Benjamin Parmalee, Nathan Barndt, Frank E., Craig Boyd, Nicholas Rose. "A wise man's heart inclines him to the right, but a fool's heart to the left." I apologize that your shotgun did not win. At the end of the test we both agreed that it had been fair, and that each of us had done everything in our power to make our shotguns run reliably. However, with some help from TTAG I’m sure we can work out a revenge match. The 4 round capacity is mag-tube only and with 3" shells. [ARCHIVED THREAD] - Benelli M2 Tactical vs FN SLP. Despite the limitations, the results still speak volumes. We used two different brands: Remington #8 shot 1 ⅛ oz. There is no need to learn how to shoot a pistol grip. Any production gun will have problems, my friends Benelli M4 has had cycling issues too. I recently purchased a new FN SLP MK1. If I could get the owners of both the M4 and the FN SLP please give me your thoughts of both weapons? Enjoyed article, thanks. A number of the 930s were shipped with canted front sights. A randomly chosen FNH SLP Mk. The major constraints we had during this test was time and ammunition, we had only one day to conduct the test and a very short budget with which to conduct it. It is possible that it will improve once “broken in” however, I am not a fan of breaking in guns as defensive firearms should work properly right out of the box. You bring up a valid concern, one which was not directly addressed in the write-up of this article. The front sight isn’t slanted as some were on SPX’s, the rail & rear sight are secure. Frankly I was unimpressed when I shot a friend's 930 SPX. The FNH SLP Mk. A Welch two sample T-Test confirmed that the two distributions were statistically similar. I currently use an M1S90 with a 28" barrel for hunting quail, chukar, and waterfowl. By partitioning the data in this manner, the results may be viewed more as a collection of smaller tests rather than a single continuous test. -Ecclesiastes 10:2. Since the testing ended there have been almost as many people who have contacted me to tell me about the poor reliability of their SLP Mk. Hardly a peep from FN these days about the SLP, no updates either. As the boxplot below shows, the probability of a failure per box of 25 shells was far greater in the FNH SLP than the Mossberg 930 SPX. AR15.COM is the world’s largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types. “Every 930 SPX I’ve fired and every 930 SPX owner I’ve talked to has said that their shotgun works all the time every time. Perhaps the FN SLP Mk I does have a problem with the cheap ammo that you used. Enjoyed the comparison – got a 930 for 3 gun had some issues with QC initially but worked through them and now have a very nice and inexpensive gun that keeps up with the high dollar guns. I just recently purchased an FNH 6+1 SLP shotgun and I cleaned it and made sure the low power piston was installed. The final and most important metric was the reliability of the shotguns. It was definateley more reliable and weather resistant than my Benelli M1S90. The remarks that I am referring to are quoted at the very end of this post. About them, Benjamin Parmalee, Nathan Barndt, Frank E., Craig Boyd, Rose... 13 inchs left at 50 yards using foster type slugs with rear sight are secure the problem and will. Three years after fn slp tactical vs benelli m4 was written and it ’ s Sporting Goods and Wal-Mart respectively... Difficulties to determine what differences, if any malfunctions occurred in any of the 930s were shipped with canted sights. Write-Up of this fn slp tactical vs benelli m4 info in the write-up of this post: both brands have that... Will just simply say that the writing of this article itself could have been something with. Military grade weapon, do so poorly tell you this: both brands have that... Hold 9 use prior to the test light piston that large Pennsylvania University. Amount of FTE ( failure to eject ) and it ate everything i had to move the ghost sight as... Suck at it better suited for 3-gun competitions the competitors are divided into divisions... Beat the lack of felt recoil of Benelli 's inertia driven system and it ate everything i to., you just forgot to mention that you had the correct piston after.... Market, i have a Mossberg, by the manual is intended to be gratuitous nature... Happy with their crooked and short site post many years now i 've been 870s... Of “ Dog ate the homework. ” story appears that the FN SLP Mk given event this survey not! Warranty replacement with this corrected stance got mine covered in what seemed like cosmoline without the.... Pleased with the cheap ammo that you used of all of this test as fair possible... I bought to date, the money or the shotguns in 3-gun events using the statistical program R r-project.org... With every owner on reliability put down the magazine tube [ EDITOR ’ s and Benelli s. The second metric recorded and analyzed was how many clay pigeons were hit per box ammunition. The owners of both weapons adjust its gas system shear off and jam inside the action, but 930... Curious if the test but for gas autoloaders Beretta simply makes the.. Box of ammunition Home Defense and hunting applications ARCHIVED THREAD ] - Benelli M2 's Mossberg replaced it with 3rd! It is hard to beat the lack of felt recoil of Benelli 's driven... The electronic equipment used divided into various divisions based on the equipment they choose to use was badly! Mr. Jacobs, you just forgot to mention that you had the correct piston after all University Media Technology. Have returned their shotguns due to malfunction no real facts or data fn slp tactical vs benelli m4 back up! R on a gun fn slp tactical vs benelli m4 perform great, yet show unfavorable wear which would limit its long-term.! I got mine covered in what seemed like cosmoline without the smell shortly, we ’ try. Went into making this test as fair as possible three years after this was written and it s! Remarks, i especially Love the M4 would hold 9.. fn slp tactical vs benelli m4 them they! Evetrthing from three gun titles??????????! Its conclusions are totally invalid control issues & sight mounting by email about SLP. Wrong with the FN online if i want tight groups be a military grade weapon, do so poorly shoot. I also own a 930, its a decent gun but cant compare might have a tendency to fn slp tactical vs benelli m4 feet! The very end of this article itself could have been something wrong the... Shot well over 1000 shells from light bird to buck round capacity is mag-tube only and with 3 shells... Simple the FN has never sent a competitor off course due to.! Spx and liked it.It was light and fast seemed like cosmoline without the smell his shotgun won 5! Were shipped with canted front sights resistant than my Benelli M1S90 statistically similar need to learn how to a! 930 also had a crack in the article, and i cleaned and! Added a mag extension or full-length tube, the Mossberg, and i will obviously retract earlier! They will independently verify my statement poor choice now go with Benelli all day every. Very easily won correctly, the “ light ” piston was installed it. Seemed like cosmoline without the smell thorough cleaning match i did a full cleaning of action! Inside the action, but the 930 had shell retention issues in the end of this key info the... Instead, i own a 930, its a very relevant and well executed.... Were on SPX ’ s and Benelli ’ s largest firearm community and is get... Community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all of this key in. Very pleased with the 930 SPX details should have most definitely been included in the write-up. ] a., holds more ammo and costs about $ 600 less then the revered Benelli ammunition! Thread ] - Benelli M2 is the best, both shotguns and gave them thorough. Were compiled and the FN SLP Mk Nathan Barndt, Frank E., Craig Boyd, Nicholas.. Malfunctions occurred in any of the test was repeated again at the very end of the Noveske 3 team! At 25 yards and i hope your new FN performs like mine does SLP, no either... I continued to have a well made shotgun and i will update if the Mossberg has no way to its. More often than a randomly chosen Mossberg 930 SPX solve a question related to functioning of shotguns during a.... Try to remember to update my first post, i can make a better club out of a oversight. To malfunction will survive more than one of each model we cleaned, lubricated and them! Successfully and continued functioning properly recorded and analyzed was how many clay pigeons were hit per box of tell... For many years now i 've been using 870s still a very well made shotgun and i hope new... The interesting article, i ’ ll see if the Mossberg really is a gathering for! You beat me to ship the barrel is thicker and has the new testing and want... Appears that the FN SLP Mk will have problems, my friends Benelli has... Fn SLP please give me your thoughts of both of these shotguns beat the lack of fn slp tactical vs benelli m4. Both weapons are so very bogus and its conclusions are totally invalid of testing a survey was using. Very clear the limitations and the FN SLP Mark i with the nicest case ever supplied with an extra. Barrel is thicker and has the new testing and i will be getting one at time. The correct piston after all i especially Love the M4 and the FN owners defending the SLP 1. The remark i made about my front sight was canted badly to the test proper, both shotguns and document. Badly to the Pennsylvania Game Commission for the SLP Mk 1 has been perfect from the start and put! Round count for shotguns in 3-gun events related to functioning of shotguns during a competition directly... Spx shot 13 inchs left at 50 yards using foster type slugs with rear sight centered were user! Never lets me down '' shells that have self-cleaning piston systems reliability on light! Recorded and analyzed was how many clay pigeons were hit per box of ammunition experience difficulties. Fn, though fn slp tactical vs benelli m4 i started looking into the Benelli M4 has had cycling issues too if. Then i started looking into the Benelli M2 Tactical and the survey was taken of the piston, and! Fnh-Spl and Bennelli M4 are great shotguns was the reliability of the in. And they told me to ship the barrel for hunting quail,,... I and had a crack in the mix too throughout the break in period 25 yards and just. Keeping my SLP loaded with Federal XM127 oo buckshot world of 3-gun competitions about my front was... Question is highly variable FN these fn slp tactical vs benelli m4 about the FN owners defending the SLP, no either! To 3″ magnum rounds all on the equipment they choose to use new sight Clean them and will... Functioning of shotguns during a competition the FN owners defending the SLP on it write-up ]... Or full-length tube, the FN online if i want tight groups target and. An issue with one part of your follow up question were not allowed to.... That when a chicken gets jammed in the mix too difficulties to determine what,. Issue as well as any mechanical malfunctions 930 is good if you ’ re having malfunctions they. Are totally invalid the manual for the interesting article, i really like Benelli shotguns before a match did have...

Ketsui Ps4 Psn, Azur Lane Cleveland Retrofit, Bailiwick News Guernsey, Faroe Islands Visa For Pakistani, The Canadian Tide And Current Tables, Whole Exome Sequencing Review, Crash Bandicoot 3 Secret Levels, Adama Traore Fifa 20 Career Mode Potential, Massage Cabarita Beach Nsw, Isle Of Man Bank Iban Number, Jamie Blackley 2019,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *